Online platforms’ shaping of data access under the GDPR: an empirical study of the uses of data download packages

Janssen, H., Carrière, T.C., Ausloos, J., Struminskaya, B., Boeschoten, L. & Araujo, T.
Data & Policy, vol. 8, 2026

Abstract

Access rights in the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) aim to empower individuals, but these also hold potential for lawful purposes beyond individual data protection. Researchers may for instance ask individuals to donate data they obtained from access requests to online platforms for academic research. Online platforms increasingly respond to such access requests by sending individuals a “data download package” (“DDP”), i.e., a technical file containing personal information data subjects are entitled to under the GDPR. Although these DDPs could, in theory, appropriately inform data subjects, practice shows that online platforms use DDPs to operationalise access rights, resulting in defective and constrained interpretations of their GDPR obligations. We compared eight online platform DDPs with that platform’s privacy notice. We found that none of the platform DDPs provide complete and individualised information as required under the GDPR, indicating a systematic lack of compliance in platforms’ responses to access requests. We conclude that the vaguely formulated access rights under the GDPR, at first sight, could give online platforms the impression that room for their own interpretation and implementation exists; yet regulatory guidance and case law have firmly narrowed down a data controller’s own access rights interpretations, also those through uses of DDPs. In this article, we refer to such platforms’ practices as “interpretative entrepreneurship”: practices whereby online platforms may reinterpret legal obligations applying to them, to subtly prioritise their own interests, while, often unobtrusively, sidestepping regulatory guidelines.

data access, GDPR, Online platforms, Privacy

RIS

Save .RIS

Bibtex

Save .bib

Een reactie op ‘Scripties, AI en het grote gemis’: Waarom we onze studenten in de ogen moeten kijken download

Nederlands Juristenblad (NJB), iss. : 35, num: 1997, pp: 2995, 2026

Abstract

Hoe moeten we omgaan met AI gebruik door scriptiestudenten? Dat is het onderwerp van een recent Vooraf. Vraag is of de daar geopperde oplossingen zullen werken.

RIS

Save .RIS

Bibtex

Save .bib

Op-Ed: “AI, News, and Copyright: Drawing the Lines after AG Szpunar’s Opinion in Like Company (C-250/25)” external link

EU Law Live, 2026

Abstract

Advocate General (AG) Szpunar’s Opinion in Like Company (C-250/25), delivered on 3 November 2026, offers the Court of Justice its first opportunity to address generative AI and copyright. Its central message is that the legal questions raised by AI cannot be resolved without distinguishing how a model is trained from how a chatbot retrieves and presents information. Although that distinction is persuasive, the Opinion also exposes challenging questions about the protection of press content, the territorial reach of EU law, and the limits of copyright as a response to AI.

Artificial intelligence, Copyright, news

RIS

Save .RIS

Bibtex

Save .bib

Public AI and Copyright external link

Quintais, J. & Rognstad, O.A.
2026

Abstract

Public Artificial Intelligence (AI) initiatives seek to combine public accountability, public interest objectives and open or equitable access to AI infrastructures and models. Their development nevertheless depends on legal frameworks that do not recognise Public AI as a distinct category. This article examines how European Union copyright law and the AI Act enable and constrain Public AI development and dissemination. It combines doctrinal and policy analysis with a documentary survey of European initiatives and case studies of GPT-NL and the Norwegian National Library's licensing arrangements with Kopinor. The analysis identifies meaningful but unevenly available legal space. Article 3 of the Copyright in the Digital Single Market Directive provides a mandatory, unremunerated text and data mining exception for qualifying institutions conducting scientific research. But uncertainty persists concerning lawful access, collaborative development and the dissemination or deployment of resulting models. The AI Act adds copyright compliance and training data transparency obligations, while its research exclusions and open-source exemptions provide limited flexibility. The case studies reveal contrasting approaches to dataset access, licensing, remuneration and downstream use. They also expose a tension between negotiated licensing and the practical effectiveness of the research exception. The article argues for targeted clarification of the existing framework rather than a separate Public AI regime. Licensing should facilitate access and authorise uses outside Article 3 without becoming a condition for activities already permitted by it. Clearer coordination with the AI Act is also needed to support collaborative research and model dissemination.

Artificial intelligence, Copyright

RIS

Save .RIS

Bibtex

Save .bib

Towards a compliant Mobile Ecosystems Design: Exploring laws applying to apps, app stores, cloud and operating systems. external link

RIS

Save .RIS

Bibtex

Save .bib

Building a public mobile stack: A framework to align European mobile stack alternatives with user values and EU laws external link

Lämmerhirt, D., Janssen, H., Dullaert, I., Valk, E.G., Toepoel, I. & Cordoba Lenis, C.
2026

Abstract

This report explains how alternative European mobile technology can better reflect user values and needs while complying with applicable EU law. The report is part of a broader effort to build European digital public infrastructure. Our central argument is that developing ethical mobile stack layers is not a neutral process: it requires working directly with user groups and grounding design choices in EU law. As mobile stack layers increasingly function as infrastructure, offering essential services to a wide range of users with different needs across societal sectors, broad policy goals or appeals to abstract ‘public values’ are not sufficient on their own to guide those developing the mobile stack. This report is the outcome of research conducted under Mobifree, a Horizon-funded innovation action project developing a human-centred and ethical mobile stack for European citizens and organisations.

RIS

Save .RIS

Bibtex

Save .bib

The Person Familiar with the Existing Work (PFEW) in Pelham II: A Workable Copyright Standard? external link

Quintais, J. & Jütte, B.J.
pp: 19, 2026

Abstract

The Court of Justice’s ruling in Pelham II (Case C-590/23) requires national courts to assess whether a new creation constitutes a pastiche under Article 5(3)(k) of Directive 2001/29/EC from the perspective of a person familiar with the existing work (the PFEW), rather than by examining the subjective intention of the pasticheur. However, the Court does not define the characteristics of this hypothetical person. Similar personae have been developed in patent, trademark and design law, where they perform specific functions in assessing the subsistence and infringement of rights. Examining how these hypothetical persons are constructed helps to identify the characteristics of the PFEW and to develop a structured test that operationalises the substantive criteria for pastiche from that person’s perspective. This article develops the concept of the PFEW and argues that they must have knowledge of the reproduced subject matter, together with knowledge of the author and the genre from which the existing work originates, sufficient to identify that work’s characteristic elements but falling short of expert knowledge. That person must also be familiar with the artistic practices and techniques used to create a pastiche.

Copyright, pastiche

RIS

Save .RIS

Bibtex

Save .bib

The Double Darkness of Dark Patterns external link

Journal of Consumer Policy, vol. 49, num: 34, 2026

Abstract

Dark patterns are as omnipresent as they are annoying. In the European Union, the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive and Digital Services Act (and in the near future, possibly, the Digital Fairness Act) regulate dark patterns. In this article, I argue that the conceptual treatment of dark patterns in the literature is problematically imprecise. Descriptive and normative considerations are often not clearly distinguished and the use of key influence concepts–e.g., deception, manipulation–also tends to be imprecise. I argue that we need to appreciate the inherent conceptual entwinement of descriptive and normative elements in a plausible concept of dark patterns. To that effect, I propose that the “dark” in dark patterns refers to two distinct–but intrinsically linked–senses of dark, one of which is descriptive in nature, and one of which is normative. I call this the double darkness of dark patterns. By embracing dark patterns’ double darkness, we can also theorise more systematically how dark patterns undermine autonomy. This, in turn, is very helpful because both the UCPD and DSA safeguard autonomy without defining or theorising it. Instead, these pieces of legislation indirectly operationalise autonomy by specifying normative influence-types (e.g., deception, manipulation, coercion, undue influence, harassment) which can “distort” or “impair” decision-making. The double darkness approach helps explaining how both senses of darkness can be systematically linked to the normative influence-types so central to legal interpretation, thereby providing more conceptual clarity specifically for legal and policy discussions of dark patterns.

RIS

Save .RIS

Bibtex

Save .bib

The CJEUʼs Judgment in IKEA v Vlaams Belang (CJEU, C-298/23) – How Much Political Expression Can EU Trade Mark Law Accommodate? external link

EHRC Updates Jurisprudentie, 2026

RIS

Save .RIS

Bibtex

Save .bib

‘De adoptie van de telegrafie in Nederland en Nederlands-Indië 1845-1914: Politieke sturing en economische betekenis’, door Fons Borm: Een beschouwing over de macht van datanetwerken download

Mediaforum, pp: 164-166, 2026

RIS

Save .RIS

Bibtex

Save .bib