Lucie Guibault is universitair hoofddocent auteursrecht en intellectuele eigendomsrecht aan het Instituut voor Informatierecht van de Universiteit van Amsterdam (UvA). Geboren en getogen in Canada, studeerde zij rechten aan de Université de Montréal [LL.B. (1988) en LL.M. (1995)] en promoveerde zij aan de UvA op het onderwerp Copyright Limitations and Contracts: An Analysis of the Contractual Overridability of Limitations on Copyright. Sinds 1997 is zij verbonden aan het Instituut voor Informatierecht. Dr. Guibault is specialist op het terrein van het internationaal en vergeleken auteursrecht en intellectuele eigendomsrecht, en spreker op nationale en internationale conferenties. Zij is tevens correspondent voor Canada en Nederland bij het Duitse juridische tijdschrift Computer und Recht International.
Creative Commons Nederland IV
Back on the Green Road: How Imperative are Imperative Rules?
Kluwer Copyright Blog
Ledenvergadering VvA: Uitleg van beperkingen
Mr. dr. L. Guibault (Lucie)
Kamer: B 2.17
T +31(0)20 525 3947
Copyright, technology and the exploitation of audiovisual works in the EU Mr. dr. L. Guibault , Mr. J.P. Quintais ,
IRIS Plus, 2014-4, p. 9-24.
Lead article in IRIS plus 2014-4.
Extended collective licensing: panacee voor massadigitalisering? Prof. mr. P.B. Hugenholtz , Dr. S.J. van Gompel , Mr. dr. L. Guibault , R. Obradović,
Onderzoek in opdracht van het Ministerie van OCW, Amsterdam, 1 september 2014.
In dit rechtsvergelijkend onderzoek wordt geanalyseerd welke voor- en nadelen de invoering van een wettelijk stelsel van extended collective licensing (‘verruimde’ collectieve licentieovereenkomsten) kan hebben om de rights clearance van digitaliseringsprojecten van erfgoedinstellingen te vergemakkelijken. Daarbij wordt een vergelijking gemaakt met de situatie waarin collectieve licenties zonder ondersteunende wettelijke maatregelen tot stand komen. De jurisdicties die zijn onderzocht zijn Denemarken, Noorwegen, Duitsland en Nederland.
Trouver le diamant dans la mine de données ou les implications juridiques de l'exploration de données Mr. dr. L. Guibault
Documentalist-Sciences de l'Information, 2014-2, p. 23-25
Standardisation in the area of innovation and technological development, notably in the field of Text and Data Mining Mr. dr. L. Guibault , dr. C.W. Handke , I. Hargreaves, P. Valcke, B. Martens,
Report from the Expert Group.
Text and data mining (TDM) is an important technique for analysing and extracting new insights and knowledge from the exponentially increasing store of digital data ('Big Data'). It is important to understand the extent to which the EU's current legal framework encourages or obstructs this new form of research and to assess the scale of the economic issues at stake.
Safe to be open: Study on the protection of research data and recommendations for access and usage Mr. dr. L. Guibault , Dr. T. Margoni , A. Wiebe (ed.),
With contributions by Nils Dietrich, Lucie Guibault, Thomas Margoni, Krzysztof Siewicz, Gerald Spindler and Andreas Wiebe.
See also the summary of findings
Licensing Research Data under Open Access Conditions Mr. dr. L. Guibault in: D. Beldiman (ed.), Information and Knowledge: 21st Centurt Challenges in Intellectual Property and Knowledge Governance,
Cheltenham: Edward Elgar ,
Digital Consumers and the Law: Towards a Cohesive European Framework Mr. dr. L. Guibault , Prof. dr. N. Helberger , Mr. drs. B. van der Sloot , M.B.M. Loos, C. Mak, L. Pessers,
Information Law Series, nr. 28, Alphen aan den Rijn: Kluwer Law International 2013,
This book provides a critical analysis of how digitisation affects established concepts and policies in consumer law. Based on evidence of the actual experience and problems encountered by consumers in digital markets, the book offers a ground-breaking study of the main issues arising in relation to the application of general consumer and sector-specific law. An interdisciplinary team of researchers from the Centre for the Study of European Contract Law (CSECL) and the Institute for Information Law (IViR), both University of Amsterdam, combine their expertise in general consumer and contract law, telecommunications law, media law, copyright law and privacy law in a joint effort to point the way to a truly cohesive European Framework for Digital Consumers and the Law. Topics in this book include the characteristics of digital content markets and how they relate to traditional consumer law; consumer concerns, reasonable expectations and how they are protected by law; the difficult question of the classification of digital content; legal questions triggered by prosumers and underage consumers; the feasibility and future of the information approach to consumer protection; the role of fundamental rights considerations, and the legal implications of an economy that uses personal data as the new currency. Digital Consumers and the Law is an important analysis for all those interested or involved in the regulation of digital content markets. With its comprehensive discussion of a wide range of fundamental as well as praxis-oriented questions, it is an essential read for academics, policy makers, members of the content industry as well as consumer representatives.
Flexible Copyright: The Law and Economics of Introducing and Open Norm in the Netherlands Mr. dr. L. Guibault , Dr. S.J. van Gompel , Dr. J.P. Poort , Mr. J.M. Breemen , R. van der Noll, J. Weda, I. Akker ,
Rapport in opdracht van het Ministerie van Economische Zaken, Landbouw en Innovatie, SEO-rapport nr. 2012-60, augustus 2012.
Zie ook aanbiedingsbrief Tweede Kamer.
This study analyses the law and economics of introducing flexibility in the system of exceptions and limitations in Dutch copyright law. Flexibility would exist in an open norm, on the basis of which the courts can decide whether certain uses of copyrighted material are permissible or not, instead of explicitly defining this in the law. The report assesses problem areas where the lack of flexibility creates legal disputes and potential barriers to innovation and production. The core of the study concerns the analysis of the economic rationale and effects of introducing flexibility in the Dutch legal order in the form of an open norm.
Clash of cultures - integrating copyright and consumer law Prof. dr. N. Helberger , Mr. dr. L. Guibault ,
Info, 2012-6, p. 23-33
In digital content markets, access to and use of digital content products are largely subject to contractual agreements and licensing conditions between suppliers and consumers. The fact that consumers acquire digital content by way of contractual arrangements implies that their relationship with the suppliers of these products is governed by two sets of rules: consumer law and copyright law. Attempts to integrate copyright and consumer law and policy and to accommodate the interests of the consumer of copyright protected content soon encounter conceptual and political challenges. The question that this article examines is what the main conceptual differences between consumer and copyright law, and the resulting ‘‘clash of cultures’’ are that need to be overcome before dealing successfully with copyright law related matters in consumer law.
The Press Exception in the Dutch Copyright Act Mr. dr. L. Guibault in: A Century of Dutch Copyright Law. Auteurswet 1912-2012, P.B. Huegnholtz, A.A. Quaedvlieg & D.J.G Visser (eds.),
Amsterdam: deLex 2012 , p. 554 ISBN 9789086920372.
Digital content contracts for consumers Mr. dr. L. Guibault , Prof. dr. N. Helberger , M.B.M. Loos, C. Mak & L. Pessers,
Journal of Consumer Policy, 2013-1, p. 37-57
The application of consumer law to digital content contracts encounters a number of obstacles. Some of these are rather typical for digital content markets, e.g., the legal consequences of the classification of digital content as “goods” or “services” and, more importantly, the absence of general benchmarks to evaluate the conformity of digital content. Other problems, such as the limited usefulness of consumer information and the position of underage consumers, are not as such reserved to digital consumers, but they are amplified in the digital content markets. Moreover, particular attention is paid to the complex relationship between copyright law and consumer law. This paper explores the extent to which consumer (contract) law is fit to address the problems faced by digital consumers wishing to enjoy the benefits of digital content and examines whether the on-going initiatives at national and European level are likely to provide relief. Finally, recommendations for improvement are put forward in cases where the analysis shows that the problems identified are not or are insufficiently solved by these initiatives.
Digital content services for consumers: Comparative analysis of the applicable legal frameworks and suggestions for the contours of a model system of consumer protection in relation to digital content Prof. dr. N. Helberger , Mr. dr. L. Guibault , Mr. drs. B. van der Sloot , M.B.M. Loos, C. Mak, L. Pessers, A. Kadouch & D. Baidoo,
Report 1: Country reports, Centre for the Study of European Contract Law (CSECL) & Institute for Information Law (IViR), 2012.
The Centre for the Study of European Contract Law (CSECL) and the Institute for Information Law (IViR) were commissioned by the European Commission to conduct a study on digital content services for consumers. This report contains the country reports of 9 Member States - Finland, France, Germany, Hungary, Italy, The Netherlands, Poland, Spain and the United Kingdom - and two legal systems from outside the EU, i.e. Norway and the United States. The country reports contain the responses of national experts to a questionnaire developed by the CSECL and the IViR.
The Netherlands: Darfurnica, Miffy and the right to parody! Mr. dr. L. Guibault
Jipitec, 2011-3, p. 236-248
The legal community of the Netherlands let out a sigh of relief in May 2011 when the judgment of the District Court of The Hague in preliminary proceedings was handed down in the Darfurnica case. The same feeling of satisfaction prevailed, more recently, when the Court of Appeal of Amsterdam rendered decision in the Miffy case. Both decisions, rendered on appeal, overruled the judgments of first instance, which had given precedence to the protection of intellectual property rights above the user's freedom of expression in the form of parody. But freedom of expression, and parody in particular, are solidly anchored in the Dutch values and courts more often than not find in favour of the parodist. Apart from the fact that both decisions offer an interesting analysis of where the limit lies between intellectual property protection and artistic freedom, each decision deserves a few words of commentary in view of some noteworthy particularities.
Brussels Memorandum of Understanding inzake digitalisering en online beschikbaarstelling van out-of-commerce boeken en tijdschriften Mr. dr. L. Guibault A.C. Beunen,
AMI, 2011-6, p. 221-226
Op 20 september 2011 werd in Brussel middels een Memorandum of Understanding ('MoU') tussen diverse belanghebbenden overeenstemming bereikt over een clearingmodel voor de digitalisering en online beschikbaarstelling door culturele instellingen van zogenaamde 'out-of-commerce' boeken en tijdschriften. Deze bijdrage bespreekt de drie in het MoU gekozen principes en de daarin gebezigde belangrijkste begrippen.
Solving Europeana's mass-digitization issues through Extended Collective Licensing? Mr. dr. L. Guibault , Mr. J. Axhamn ,
Nordiskt Immateriellt Rättsskydd, 2011-6, p. 509-516
The ever increasing use of the Internet and of digitization technologies have opened up new possibilities for distributing and accessing creative content online, including for cultural heritage institutions. However, the digitization and dissemination of a substantial proportion of the collections held by European cultural institutions maybe considerably hindered due to high transaction costs related to clearance of copyright and related rights. This holds equally true for the cultural institutions taking part in the Europeana project. A recent study - Cross-border extended collective licensing: a solution to online dissemination of Europe's cultural heritage - examines whether the Nordic 'extended collective licensing' (ECL) model could provide a viable solution to the problems of digitization and dissemination of copyright protected works held by cultural heritage institutions, with a brief incursion into the issue of the cross-border dissemination of works. This article summarises the main findings of the study.
The Regulation of Digital Content Contracts in the Optional Instrument of Contract Law Mr. dr. L. Guibault , Prof. dr. N. Helberger , M.B.M. Loos, C. Mak,
European Review of Private Law, 2011-6, p. 729-758
The past decade has shown a rapid development of the markets for digital content. The further development of these markets, however, may be hindered because of the lack of a functioning legal framework to deal with digital content contracts. In this article, it is argued that the future Optional Instrument should contain rules governing digital content contracts. Moreover, suggestions are made as to the content of such rules.
Analysis of the applicable legal frameworks and suggestions for the contours of a model system of consumer protection in relation to digital content contracts ( ) Prof. dr. N. Helberger , Mr. dr. L. Guibault , Mr. drs. B. van der Sloot , M.B.M. Loos, C. Mak, L. Pessers, K.J. Cseres & R. Tigner,
Final report, comparative analysis, law & economics analysis, assessment and development of recommendations for possible future rules on digital content contracts.
Zie voor meer informatie ook de website van de Europese Commissie.
Report of the Netherlands Mr. dr. L. Guibault in: The Balance of Copyright, a Comparative Approach, R.M. Hilty & S. Nérisson (eds.), K. van 't Klooster,
Cross-border extended collective licensing: a solution to online dissemination of Europe’s cultural heritage? Mr. dr. L. Guibault , Mr. J. Axhamn ,
Onderzoek in opdracht van EuropeanaConnect, Amsterdam, Instituut voor Informatierecht, augustus 2011.
In: Collective Management of Copyright and Related Rights, D. Gervais (ed.), 2de dr., Alphen aan de Rijn: Kluwer Law International, 2010, p. 135-167.
This chapter examines efforts to regulate the collective management of copyright at the European level. It is divided in three main parts. First, the chapter describes the current state of the law concerning collective rights management organizations (CMOs) in Europe, as pronounced over the past few decades in decisions of the European Court of Justice and the European Commission in competition matters. Second, the chapter discusses the recent efforts deployed by the European lawmakers toward the establishment of a legal framework governing the activities of CMOs in Europe, and more specifically the multi-territorial licensing of online music services. The third part analyses the actual and potential impact on the market for the cross-border collective management of legitimate online music services of the most recent measures adopted by the European bodies. The chapter critically concludes on the overall state of the law in Europe pertaining to CMOs.
Open Content Licensing from Theory to Practice - An Introduction Mr. dr. L. Guibault in: Open Content Licensing: From Theory to Practice, L. Guibault & C. Angelopoulos (ed.),
Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press 2011, p. 7-20
Owning the Right to Open Up Access to Scientific Publications Mr. dr. L. Guibault in: Open Content Licensing: From Theory to Practice, L. Guibault & C. Angelopoulos (ed.),
Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press 2011, p. 137-167
Open Content Licensing from Theory to Practice Mr. dr. L. Guibault , Mr. C.J. Angelopoulos , ed.,
This book assembles chapters written by renowned European scholars on a number of selected issues relating to open content licensing. It offers a comprehensive and objective study of the principles of open content from a European intellectual property law perspective and of their possible implementation in practice.
Report of the Netherlands for ALAI 2011 Study Days (Dublin) Prof. mr. M.M.M. van Eechoud , Dr. S.J. van Gompel , Mr. dr. L. Guibault , Mr. drs. B. van der Sloot , Prof. mr. P.B. Hugenholtz ,
Contrary to other types of open content licenses, Creative Commons licenses are intended to be translated and adapted to the laws of a maximum of jurisdictions in the world. Local or regional peculiarities of the copyright regime can sometimes require an adaptation to the licenses that would disrupt their worldwide similarity. This article focuses on one of these peculiarities: the European sui generis database right. It describes how the database right was excluded from the scope of the Creative Commons licenses and discusses the possible consequences of such an exclusion for the Creative Commons movement and for the users of the licenses in Europe.
Annotatie bij Rb. Amsterdam 20 mei 2009 (Iglesias & Jungle Aire / Sony BMG) Mr. dr. L. Guibault
AMI, 2010-2, nr. 7, p. 70-75
Overdracht en licentiëring van naburige rechten. Aanhoudende contractuele verhouding tussen uitvoerend kunstenaar en platenmaatschappij waarbij een reeks overeenkomsten werd gesloten voor en na de inwerkingtreding van de WNR. Vraag of deze overeenkomsten ook betrekking hebben op digital exploitatiemogelijkheden. Uit de aard en strekking van de overeenkomsten volgt geen rechtenoverdracht, maar wel een onbeperkte en exclusieve licentie, die ook op de digitale exploitatiemogelijkheden betrekking heeft.
Why Cherry Picking Never Leads to Harmonisation: The Case of the Limitations on Copyright under Directive 2001/29/EC Mr. dr. L. Guibault
Jipitec, 2010-2, p. 55-66
The article examines whether the norms laid down in the Directive in relation to the exceptions and limitations on copyright and related rights can be conducive to a sensible degree of harmonisation across the European Union. Before discussing the degree of harmonisation achieved so far by the Directive, the first part gives a short overview of the main characteristics of the list op exceptions and limitations contained in Article 5 of the Directive. A comprehensive review of the implementation of each limitation by the Member States is beyond the scope of this article. The following section takes a closer look at three examples of limitations that have led to legislative changes at the Member State level as express measures towards the implementation of the Information Society Directive, that is, the limitations for the benefit of libraries, for teaching and research, and for persons with a disability. These exceptions and limitations were later on also identified by the European Commission as key elements in the deployment of a digital knowledge economy. The analysis will show that the implementation of the provisions on limitations in the Information Society Directive did not, and probably cannot, yield the expected level of harmonisation across the European Union and that, as a consequence, there still exists a significant degree of uncertainty for the stakeholders regarding the extent of permissible acts with respect to copyright protected works.
User-Created-Content: Supporting a participative Information Society, Final Report Prof. dr. N. Helberger , Mr. dr. L. Guibault , Mr. E.H. Janssen , Mr. C.J. Angelopoulos , Dr. J.V.J. van Hoboken , Prof. dr. N.A.N.M. van Eijk , E. Swart, et al.,
Studie in opdracht van de Europese Commissie, uitgevoerd door IDATE, TNO en IViR.
The European Concern with Copyright and Related Rights Dr. S.J. van Gompel , Mr. dr. L. Guibault , Prof. mr. M.M.M. van Eechoud ,
In: Harmonizing European Copyright Law: The Challenges of Better Lawmaking, Information Law Series, nr. 19, Alphen aan den Rijn: Kluwer Law International 2009.
Harmonizing European Copyright Law: The Challenges of Better Lawmaking Dr. S.J. van Gompel , Prof. mr. M.M.M. van Eechoud , Mr. dr. L. Guibault , Prof. dr. N. Helberger , Prof. mr. P.B. Hugenholtz ,
Information Law Series, nr. 19, Alphen aan den Rijn: Kluwer Law International 2009,
Hoofdstuk 1: The European Concern with Copyright and Related Rights;
Hoofdstuk 9:The Last Frontier: Territoriality;
Nobody likes today’s copyright law. Widespread unauthorized use of copyright material proliferates with impunity, while citizens and users protest that intrusive copyright and related rights law stifle cultural expression. Equipment manufacturers and intermediaries complain about yet more ’security’ features that complicate their products and services and encumber marketing, while content owners desperately want enforcement to work. And of course it is crucial that whatever regulatory instruments come into play must not age prematurely in Internet time. The European Union faces the daunting challenge of articulating coherent copyright policies that satisfy these contradictory multiple demands. Yet the legal framework must conform to the European Union’s remit of fostering economic growth in a common market, while respecting the national traditions of its still growing family of Member States. Clearly, an extraordinary balancing act is called for if justice is to be done to all of the private and public interests affected. So how has the European acquis communautaire scored on these issues so far? In this groundbreaking study the Institute for Information Law of the University of Amsterdam brings its extensive academic expertise to bear on this question. The authors scrutinize the present law as laid down in the seven copyright and related rights directives, against the background of the relevant international standards of the Berne Convention, the TRIPs agreement, and the WIPO Internet Treaties. They map out in detail the degree to which certain areas of copyright have been harmonized as they expose the gaps and inconsistencies in the acquis and the urgent unresolved issues that persist. They identify the EU’s ambitions in relation to its present and future competences (following the Lisbon Reform) to regulate copyright, and to its Better Regulation agenda. Following a comprehensive analysis of almost two decades of regulatory intervention, they move on to the salient current trends that point toward a more coherent and balanced European copyright law.
Onderzoek in opdracht van Kennisnet.
Creative Commons: Struggling to ‘Keep it Simple’ Mr. dr. L. Guibault in: Conference Proceedings KnowRight 08,
Wenen: Österreichische Computer Gesellschaft 2008, p. 75-83
Accommodating the Needs of iConsumers: Making Sure They Get Their Money's Worth of Digital Entertainment Mr. dr. L. Guibault
Journal of Consumer Policy, 2008-4, p. 409
Halleluja: Buma's aansluitvoorwaarden krijgen zegen van NMa! Mr. dr. L. Guibault
AMI, 2008-4, p. 85-93
Evaluatie van de artikelen 29a en 29b van de Auteurswet 1912 Mr. G.J.H.M. Mom , Mr. dr. L. Guibault ,
Onderzoek in opdracht van het WODC (Ministerie van Justitie).
De komst van de digitale netwerkomgeving als een commercieel levensvatbaar platform voor het verspreiden van auteursrechtelijk beschermd materiaal, heeft het noodzakelijk gemaakt de bescherming van de rechthebbenden op dit materiaal (de 'content') te versterken en uit te breiden. Deze studie beoogt de achtergrond en werking van de Nederlandse bepalingen betreffende de rechtsbescherming van technische voorzieningen en van informatie over het beheer van rechten (artikelen 29a en 29b Auteurswet) beknopt te inventariseren en analyseren.
Study on the Implementation and Effect in Member States' Laws of Directive 2001/29/EC on the Harmonisation of Certain Aspects of Copyright and Related Rights in the Information Society Prof. mr. M.M.M. van Eechoud , Mr. dr. L. Guibault , Prof. dr. N. Helberger , Prof. mr. P.B. Hugenholtz , G. Westkamp & T. Rieber-Mohn,
Rapport aan de Europese Commissie, DG Interne Markt, februari 2007. Zie ook Part II: Country Reports on the Implementation of Directive 2001/29/EC in the Member States, G. Westkamp, Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute, februari 2007.
This study, commissioned by the European Commission, examines the application of Directive 2001/29/EC in the light of the development of the digital market. Its purpose is to consider how Member States have implemented the Directive into national law and to assist the Commission in evaluating whether the Directive, as currently formulated, remains the appropriate response to the continuing challenges faced by the stakeholders concerned, such as rights holders, commercial users, consumers, educational and scientific users. As set out in specifications of the study set out by the Commission, its aim is "to assess the role that the Directive has played in fostering the digital market for goods and services in the four years since its adoption". The impact of the Directive on the development of digital (chiefly online) business models, therefore, will be the focal point of our enquiry throughout this study.
In: Collective Management of Copyright and Related Rights, Daniel Gervais (red.), The Hague: Kluwer Law International 2006, p. 117-152.
Wrapping Information in Contract: How Does it Affect the Public Domain? Mr. dr. L. Guibault in: The Future of the Public Domain - Identifying the Commons in Information Law, L. Guibault & P.B. Hugenholtz,
Information Law Series, nr. 16, The Hague: Kluwer Law International 2006, 87-104 pp.
Contracts are an essential tool in the distribution of information. If a specific element of information has any commercial value at all, its access and use will most likely be governed by the terms of a license, whether it is protected by an intellectual property or not. The central question addressed in this chapter is whether the use of contracts with respect to the distribution of public domain information bears any impact on the supply of information and on the composition of the public domain. Would contracts that restrict the use of public domain information or limit the exercise of uses privileged under the law be actually enforced by the courts? If so, would the use of contracts in the trade of information tend to increase the amount of information available to the public anyway? Or would it, on the contrary, withdraw from the public domain some elements of information that were until then freely available?
The Recasting of Copyright & Related Rights for the Knowledge Economy Dr. S.J. van Gompel , Prof. mr. M.M.M. van Eechoud , Mr. dr. L. Guibault , Prof. dr. N. Helberger , Prof. mr. P.B. Hugenholtz ,
Rapport aan de Europese Commissie, DG Interne Markt, november 2006, 308 p.
Zie ook de executive summary.
Study carried out by the Institute for Information Law for the European Commission (DG Internal Market). Chapters 1 and 2 describe and examine the existing 'acquis communautaire' in the field of copyright and related (neighbouring) rights, with special focus on inconsistencies and unclarities. Chapters 3-6 deal with distinct issues that were identified a priori by the European Commission as meriting special attention: possible extension of the term of protection of phonograms (Chapter 3), possible alignment of the term of protection of co-written musical works (Chapter 4), the problems connected to multiple copyright ownership, including the issue of 'orphan works' (Chapter 5), and copyright awareness among consumers (Chapter 6). Chapter 7 provides an overall assessment of the benefits and drawbacks of the fifteen years of harmonisation of copyright and related rights in the EU and dwells on regulatory alternatives.
The Future of the Public Domain - Identifying the Commons in Information Law Mr. dr. L. Guibault , Prof. mr. P.B. Hugenholtz ,
Information Law Series, nr. 16, The Hague: Kluwer Law International 2006,
Zie ook hoofdstuk 1: The Future of the Public Domain. An Introduction.
The presence of a robust public domain is an essential precondition for cultural, social and economic development and for a healthy democratic process. But the public domain is under pressure as a result of the ongoing march towards an information economy.
This book takes a broad, 'information law' oriented approach towards the question of preservering the public domain, in which a wide range of interrelated legal questions converge.
Thirteen contributions from academia worldwide make up the present book, addressing the future of the public domain from a different angle. In addition, all authors were invited to reflect upon the notion and role of the public domain in the context of information law and policy.
Unravelling the myth around open source licences : An analysis from a Dutch and European law perspective Mr. dr. L. Guibault , Mr. O.L. van Daalen ,
Information Technology & Law series, nr. 8, The Hague: T.M.C. Asser Press 2006,
Zie ook de "draft"-versie van dit boek.
This study gives an overview of the current legal situation regarding the use of open source software licences and investigates how the most commonly used open source software licences measure up to Dutch and European law. By its in-depth analysis and clear conclusions, this book contributes to the understanding of this complex field that policy makers, regulators, and academics so crucially require. Taking the provisions of the GNU GPL, the BSD, and the Mozilla Public Licence as examples, it investigates the implications of open source licensing from a private law, copyright law and patent law perspective. It also takes a brief look at the issue of the enforcement of these licences. To facilitate the use and enforcement of open source software licences in Europe, and more particularly in the Netherlands, the authors conclude their study by making a number of recommendations for the adaptation of the licence terms with a view to enhancing their compliance with the legal requirements.
Policy conclusions of the European Consumer Law Group (ECLG) based on a study carried out by L. Guibault and N. Helberger.
The purpose of this study is to provide an overview of certain key aspects of the relationship between copyright law and consumer protection. More particularly, the paper concentrates on what would appear today as the most problematic issue, from the perspective of the consumer, understood in the narrow sense of the word, namely the implementation of technological protection measures (TPM) and digital rights management (DRM) systems and its implication for the exercise of the private use exemption.
Vous qui téléchargez des oeuvres de l'Internet, pourrait-on savoir qui vous êtes? Mr. dr. L. Guibault
Revue du Droit des Technologies de l'Information, 2004-18, p. 9-31
A quand l'octroi de licences transfrontières pour l'utilisation de droits d'auteur et de droits voisins en Europe?’ Mr. dr. L. Guibault
HS (Hors série), 189-208 pp.
Copyright contract law: towards a statutory regulation? Mr. dr. L. Guibault , Prof. mr. P.B. Hugenholtz ,
Study conducted on commission for the department of Scientific Research and Documentation Centre (WODC) of the Dutch Ministry of Justice,August 2004 (Text in the Dutch language).
Auteurscontractenrecht: naar een wettelijke regeling? Mr. dr. L. Guibault , Prof. mr. P.B. Hugenholtz ,
Onderzoek in opdracht van het WODC (Ministerie van Justitie), augustus 2004.
Deze studie, die is verricht in opdracht van het WODC (Ministerie van Justitie), strekt ertoe de behoefte aan specifieke wettelijke maatregelen in Nederland te inventariseren. In het onderzoek ligt het accent op de vanuit auteursrechtelijk of nabuurrechtelijk oogpunt meest wezenlijke aspecten van de exploitatieovereenkomst: formele vereisten, de omvang en interpretatie van de rechtenverlening, het recht op vergoeding, derdenwerking van de rechtenverlening en de mogelijkheid van herziening en beëindiging van de overeenkomst. Op basis van de bevindingen worden de hoofdlijnen van een mogelijke wettelijke regeling geschetst.
The nature and scope of limitations and exceptions to copyright and neighbouring rights with regard to general interest missions for the transmission of knowledge: prospects for their adaptation to the digital environment Mr. dr. L. Guibault
Copyright Bulletin, 2003,
The Future of Levies in a Digital Environment Mr. dr. L. Guibault , Prof. mr. P.B. Hugenholtz , Mr. S.M. van Geffen ,
Le tir manqué de la Directive européenne sur le droit d'auteur dans la société de l'information, Mr. dr. L. Guibault
Les Cahiers de Propriété Intellectuelle, 2003-2, p. 537-573
Study on the conditions applicable to contracts relating to intellectual property in the European Union Mr. dr. L. Guibault , Prof. mr. P.B. Hugenholtz , m.m.v. M.A.R. Vermunt en M. Berghuis,
Eindrapport, studie in opdracht van de EG, mei 2002.
The cross-border exploitation of copyrighted works or performances has increased dramatically in recent years. This development is evident in respect of such ‘borderless’ media such as broadcasting and information services provided online. However, more traditional sectors of the information and entertainment industries, such as book publishing and film production, are also undergoing a process of rapid internationalisation, particularly within the European Union. As a consequence, contractual relationships between authors or performers on the one hand, and publishers, broadcasters or producers on the other hand, are increasingly taking on an international dimension. In view of the differences that presently exist at the national level regarding the law applicable to copyright contracts, this process of internationalisation has, inevitably, prompted the question whether some form of harmonisation at the European level is called for. This is the central question of this study.
Discussion paper on the question of Exceptions to and limitations on copyright and neighbouring rights in the digital era Mr. dr. L. Guibault
Raad van Europa.
Copyright Limitations and Contracts - An Analysis of the Contractual Overridability of Limitations on Copyright, Information Law Series Mr. dr. L. Guibault
Information Law Series, nr. 9, London / The Hague / Boston: Kluwer Law International 2002, pp.
Traditional copyright law strikes a delicate balance between an author’s control of original material and society’s interest in the free flow of ideas, information, and commerce. In today’s digitally networked environment, this balance has shifted dramatically to one side, as powerful rights holders contractually impose terms and conditions of use far beyond the bounds set by copyright law. This vitally significant book explores this conflict from its gestation through its current manifestations to its future lineaments and potential consequences. Focusing on statutory copyright limitations that enshrine constitutional rights such as freedom of expression and privacy, foster dissemination of knowledge, safeguard competition, and protect authors from market failure, Copyright Limitations and Contracts clearly explains the rationale for these limitations and questions the legality of overriding them by contractual means. The author finds a complex array of factors clouding the emergence of coherent rules in the matter, among them the nature of the contract (e.g., fully negotiated vs. “shrink-wrap”), the respective interests of the parties involved, and the legislated policy of particular regimes. She points out that the United States’ new Uniform Computer Information Transactions Act (UCITA), which is likely to be adopted by many U.S. States and influence similar legislation in many other countries, leaves this crucial issue essentially unresolved. Among the author’s many startling insights is that, contrary to the commonly held notion that the Internet is a bastion of free speech, in fact it is now possible (via encryption technology) for the first time in human history to exercise absolute control over copyrighted material, even under circumstances of global mass distribution. As we become more and more aware that the intersection of copyright and contract reveals one of the deepest and most far-reaching contradictions of our time, this illuminating analysis will be of extraordinary value to jurists in every area of public and private law.
Les programmes d'ordinateur et le droit d'innovation technologique Mr. dr. L. Guibault
Cahiers de Propriété Intellectuelle, -2, p. 171-202
Text in French. This articles discusses the legal protection of computer software and proposes the creation of a new sui generis right more suited to the characteristics of this technology. The proposal of a new technological innovation right arises from the experience acquired over the last twenty years with respect to computer software protection. The parameters of this new right borrows known avenues inspired by copyright law, patent law, integrated circuit topography law, as well as the new sui generis right on databases recognized in Europe. This article presents the technological innovation right: the scope of application, the exclusive rights granted and their limitations, the formalities for acquisition and the duration of the protection.
Agreements between Authors or Performers and Collective Rights Societies: Comparative Study of Some Provisions Mr. dr. L. Guibault
Canada, Montreal, 1997.
Report prepared for the 1997 ALAI Congress held in Montebello
Text in French - with the Introduction and a summary for each chapter translated into English. Available in paper format with ALAI Canada for $ 75. CDN. In the context of the 1997 Congress of the Association Littéraire et Artistique Internationale (ALAI), entitled «Protection of Authors and Performers through Contracts», the Canadian Group of ALAI wished to draw particular attention to the legal relationship existing between authors or performers and collective rights societies. The nature of the copyrights and neighbouring rights conferred by law, the legal framework surrounding the structure and operations of collective societies, their number in each territory and the presence of complementary professional associations are determining factors in the definition of the scope of protection granted to authors and performers. Taking these elements into account, this report analyzes around fifty agreements entered into by authors and performers on the one hand, and organizations whose activities consist of collecting and distributing copyrights and neighbouring rights, on the other hand. The study is divided in two main chapters, the first one dealing with the contractual relationship between members and the society, and the second one examing the extent to which members may participate in the operations of the society.
Pre-emption Issues in the Digital Environment: Can Copyright Limitations Be Overridden by Contractual Agreements under European Law? Mr. dr. L. Guibault in: Europees privaatrecht 1998. Opstellen over International Transacties en Intellectuele Eigendom, F.W. Grosheide & K. Boele-Woelki (red.),
Molengrafica, nr. 11, Lelystad: Koninklijke Vermande 1998, 225-262 pp.
General report prepared for the ALAI STUDY DAYS Cambridge, September 14-17, 1998: The Exceptions And Limitations To Copyright.